Shrinking the J.Crew Honeycomb Sweater

Left: sweater without shrinking  Right: different sweater after shrinking

J.Crew doesn’t usually fit me well, but I’ve been okay with buying their sweaters (especially simple, non-embellished ones) because in the back of my mind, I’m thinking, “oh yeah, that’ll shrink”. I picked up a few of the Honeycomb sweaters on sale, and have been wearing them as is for a little while now, but it was only a matter of time before I started getting curious about shrinking them.

Since quite a few ladies also picked up this sweater, I figured I’d post my results, so you can see how this sweater behaves in the wash. If you don’t want this sweater to shrink, you may want to dry clean it.

Note: I’m posting this only as a guide for what I did, and my unique results, in case anyone else was interested in trying it themselves. If you attemp to shrink your clothing, please know that your results may vary, and do so at your own risk.

Before shrinking:

Like my socks? =)

This is not the sweater I shrank, but here’s an idea of the fit before shrinking. Notice the length, sleeves, and fit in the torso. It’s not bad, and fine for laying, but I was curious if I could get a better fit.

What I did:

– Washed sweater on “delicate” cycle, in a wash bag, inside out, with Woolite for darks. *Forgot to mention I used cold water

Note: the sweater looked like it shrank just from going through the wash. If you do not want your sweater to shrink, do not put in the wash!

– Removed sweater from garment bag and dried in dryer on “low” for short bursts of time.

– Let air-dry the rest of the way overnight.

After shrinking:

Notice the all around smaller and shorter fit.

What happened:

The sweater shrunk all around, in all directions. Here are measurements of my non-washed spearmint sweater compared to the grey sweater after washing :

Spearmint (Non-Washed) Grey (Washed)
Shoulder: 14″ Shoulder: 13″
Armpit to armpit: 16.5″ Armpit to armpit: 15″
Sleeve: 22″ Sleeve: 21″
Length: 22″ Length: 20″

 

The knit of the sweater feels tighter, which is to be expected since the threads shrank. I hoped the dryer would alleviate some of the fuzz, but my sweater came out with little fuzz balls that are easily picked off by hand. I also went over the sweater with a sweater shaver, which helped a little bit as well. Up close, the fuzz of the washed sweater doesn’t lay as flat as the non-washed sweater.

Even though the texture of the sweater changed slightly, I like the results and will probably pop my others in the wash shortly.

See some of the other items I shrank, including J.Crew cashmere in this post. There are also some good shrinking tips in this post.

I hope this is helpful to anyone who picked up these sweaters, and either want them a little smaller, or don’t want them to shrink at all. Good luck!

49 Comments

  • Reply January 18, 2012

    Jen B

    I’m going to try it! I actually bought 2 darkish colors (blue and purple) because the lighter colors looked too huge on me. Now I’m wishing I had bought the cream one!

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      And I’m bummed I didn’t get the purple (I got the cream though!). Let me know how it works out for you! I knew you’d be curious about this yourself.  ;)

      Good luck!

  • Reply January 18, 2012

    Annie

    Hi:

    I think after wash the sweater fits you even better  : )

    btw, forget to introduce myself. I just started my blog, and find out this big petite community, which provides lots of great petite informations for me.

    thanks
    http://www.mixandmatchfashion.blogspot.com

  • Reply January 18, 2012

    Girlie Blogger

    I prefer the shrunken version on you.

    http://www.thegirlieblog.com

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Cristina

    Kelly,

    Once you shrink something, how do you wash it thereafter?  For example, if you are shrinking a dry clean only item, once you shrink it do you dry clean it moving forward or can you just continue to wash it on the delicate cycle?

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Good question Cristina! I take the behavior of the item in mind. For example, if the item instantly shrank, and then didn’t seem to shrink anymore after continued drying, such as this sweater, I’d deem it safe to wash at home going forward, since it already shrank all the way already. If I wash it at home going forward, it won’t shrink anymore, because it already did all it’s shrinking. So for this item, I’ll wash in a wash bag on cold & delicate cycle, and then let it air dry going forward (to keep the yarn in good shape since drying can damage threads and fade color). I might dry clean it every so often just so they’ll clean up any fuzz balls that will probably pop up under the arm, and where my handbag rubs.

      If the item looks like it will continue shrinking with further washing/drying, to be super safe, I’d dry clean going forward, especially if the piece is something you really love. The more delicate the item, the more caution you should take, and if you’re very worried about it, it’s probably best to bypass home shrinking and consult a knit alterations professional.

      Most knits (as long as they don’t have embellishments or panels of different kinds of fabrics) are fine to at least hand wash & lay flat to dry, but I have had some very thin knits (especially wool) come out looking wonky. Be very careful with the items you try and shrink. The texture may change, and details like zippers or button plackets may shrink at a different rate and become bumpy.

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Adding on to my last comment (sorry for the length!), synthetic blend sweaters will shrink less, so it’s safer to continue washing them post shrink. Sweaters that are all natural, like cashmere, should be handled more delicate because even if it looks like they’re done shrinking, they can continue getting smaller with each wash.

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Laura Weekly

    Thanks for this post!  I’m sure it will help a lot of people.  And I LOVE your socks!  What brand are they?

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      LOL! Thanks! They are from the J.Crew outlet. ;)

      • Reply January 19, 2012

        Sandy

        I have the greatest trouble finding socks that fit and I think my feet even slightly larger than yours!  Do you find JCrew socks fit on the smaller side?

        • Reply January 20, 2012

          Alterations Needed

          Not really, if anything, the toe on these are a little roomy, but I mostly wear them for warmth around the house, and not inside shoes. Banana Republic has nice socks, especially their “trouser socks” which are thinner, so can be worn inside non-sneaker shoes. I also buy them from the BR Factory store for cheap. =)

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    SouthMoltonStStyle

    This is very good to know, I have the same problem with J Crew sweaters. xxx

    http://www.southmoltonststyle.com

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    JJ, Pocket Sized Fashion

    Definitely fits much better after the wash! I’m always far too scared to ever shrink my wool items, but seeing how well it works is making me reconsider – although lol, I’m always reminded of the time I accidentally tossed a wool sweater in the dryer with the rest of my clothes, and it ended up so small that I gave it to my 2-year old niece as a hand-me-down ;)

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Thanks! Ay, 100% wool will shrink like crazy! This sweater is a viscose/nylon/wool blend, so I knew it wouldn’t shrink to baby sizes, but there is always a little bit of fear as I hover near the dryer, checking on the sweater every 10 seconds. =)

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Nikki

    I have a j crew sweater with a similar fit issue. I’d love to try shrinking it, but its fabric content is acrylic/wool/mohair. Have you had experience with materials like that, and if so, do you think the way I try to shrink them (washer/dryer settings or times) should vary? I just wouldn’t want the sweater to turn out to be totally unwearable.

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      The sweater from this post is viscose/nylon/wool/angora, so it’s a very similar fabric content. The artificial fibers (acrylic/viscose/nylon) don’t really shrink, but the wool will, so the blending of those fibers will *probably* result in a small amount of shrinking, similar to the results I got, but I can’t be for sure.

      Is is a loose or tight knit weave? Tight knits won’t shrink as much as loose knits, so if it’s loose, be careful!

      Does the tag say dry clean? Have you tried to hand wash it? If you haven’t, and you hand wash or put in the washer on gentle, you’ll *probably* see it come out a little smaller, since that’s what I saw with this sweater.

      You can also try being super careful, and then work your way up if you want more results. One commenter on another post of mine only wanted the torso smaller, so she sprayed water with a spray bottle just on the sweater torso, and then put it in the dryer on low heat and checked on it often. She had good results. If that’s not enough, maybe try hand wash & air dry. If that doesn’t work, try washing machine (gentle & in wash bag) with super careful dryer drying.

      Good luck if you decide to go for it!

      • Reply February 4, 2012

        Nikki

        I DID IT!! It took me this long because I am a chicken, but I finally did it- basically just following your instructions, and it worked really well. I’m considering actually doing it one more time, though I don’t know if it will shrink any more. The sweater (“Cable-stitch” sweater) is still a hair big, but the fit is much better now than it was before. Thanks for the tips!! Yay :)

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Bravoerunway

    Looking good! Well..we tweeted about my OCD with caring for clothes yesterday! My only concern is how many times you can actually run the sweater shaver after washing this sweater.  But I guess…once it has overly shrunken…what do you know…it’s time for a new one! HAHA and watch J. Crew recycle the style and put buttons on the sleeves next year…or shrink down the honeycomb weave pattern..I am so bad lol!

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      So true. Once something starts getting icky, we’re bombarded with the same thing but in the newest cut/color with all new bells and whistles. And I’m such a sucker, I totally give in. Marketing works! LOL.

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Trystan L. Bass

    That looks great! Shrinking a sweater with blended fibers is actually safer than one with 100% natural fibers — all wool / cashmere / cotton can shrink too much, too fast. The synthetic fibers don’t shrink so the overall shrinkage isn’t as dramatic. That said, I only do it with something I got on sale because the results are still unpredictable.

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Helen's lookbook

    Love your cute socks:) My mom is also petite, her special way to shrink sweaters in old days is put them into hot water, that would damage the sweater but in those days no fancy products could use, her method did a good job to make her sweaters fit.

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Christina @ CurlsNPearls

    I think you did a fine job of shrinking! :) Looks great on you.

    I am hosting a giveaway for an awesome gift from Julep, a nail and hand care company. I’d love it if you would enter – all you have to do is leave a comment. http://www.curlsnpearls.com/2012/01/18/julep-nail-polish-review-giveaway/

    Fingers crossed I’m the lucky winner of the adorable BCBG collar necklace you are giving out! ;)

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Cori Robinson

    I love your socks… and the sweater looks really great post shrinkage.  I shrink my clothes often, but I always hold my breath a little when I do it.  It’s like, do I risk ruining it or always having it fit a little too baggy.  Most of the time, its better after shrinking.  Ah, the life of a petite.  Wouldn’t it be great if getting dressed wasn’t quite so high maintenance? 

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    New Petite

    !I like the shrunken fit on you! All the best for the other sweaters! My husband put my merino wool top into washer and dryer and now it will probably fit my 2 year old!!

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Trish

    Why didnt I think of this?!?! I passed on this sweater because it was a little roomy and dry-clean-only. I hope jcrew still has some left…

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Mello

    I agree.  The shrunken fit looks better on you.

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Cee

    Alright, you’ve gotta be sick of me saying this by now, but YOUR SOCKS! It was the first thing I noticed and I think I might own the same pair, hahaha. Kinda sad that I’ve lost count of what colors/patterns I own.

    I think I prefer the shrunken sweater if you wore a collared shirt underneath because the original version looks great as is for a slouchy-casual look.

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      LOL. I was wondering if you’d notice my socks… They are J.Crew Factory, in case you’re wondering if you have the same ones.  =)

      • Reply January 19, 2012

        Michelle

        I thought the socks looked like J. Crew!  :)  My husband has accumulated so many J. Crew socks and Happy Socks, it is insane! At least he is easy to shop for!

        • Reply January 20, 2012

          Alterations Needed

          LOL! I love when boys wear fun socks. The boyfriend once had his boss stop a meeting in order to point out his ridiculously colored socks. It was a proud moment for me. Hehe.

      • Reply January 20, 2012

        Cee

        HAHA I do have the same pair! Well, almost. The polka dot colors are reversed but it’s got the same purple toe.

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    FunSizeClothes

    I love the socks, they were the first thing I noticed!  I never know which sweaters I can pop in the dryer and which ones will shrink to toddler size.  If they’re roomy, I just throw them all in and hope for the best  =D

    http://funsizeclothes.wordpress.com

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Here’s a tip for next time: Sweaters that are 100% natural fibers will shrink like crazy…often too much. But I’ve successfully shrunk cashmere. Sweaters than are synthetic/natural blends will shrink better, since the synthetic fibers don’t shrink. =)

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Jasmin

    I am not sure whether you can assume that a sweater will no longer shrink if it hasn’t done so after drying it (given that it already shrank in the washer.) I had purchased several Ralph Lauren cable sweaters many years ago that initially were too big for me. The first time I washed them they shrank to a size that was just perfect. After the second time they already become borderline too tight and too short. After the third wash the sweaters had the size of a sweater for two-year olds.  And in fact in all these cases  the drying never made any difference to the size of the sweater, meaning all the shrinking happened in the washer. Also, this happened in spite of the tag saying “handwash cold” and “tumble dry low” which is what I did.
    From my experience I would say that you have to be extra careful with sweaters that have a cable or honeycomb pattern because these tend to shrink a lot more than “normal” knit sweaters. I would rather not wash your sweaters any more but stick to having them dry cleaned now that they are the perfect size for you. The risk is too high that you may end up with a toddler’s size sweater.

    • Reply January 19, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Good point Jasmin! Thanks for bringing that up! I’ve had synthetic blends that once shrunk, refuse to get any smaller (and I’ve tried to purposely shrink them more), but I forgot about the shrinking ability of all natural fibers. I’ll point this out to the other commenter too. =)

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Michelle

    Oh! The armpit to armpit looks better if you plan on not wearing it layered!

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Leslie

    The shrunken sweater looks great on you! I usually handwash and use the water temperature to adjust the amount of shrinkage. Then I lay it flat to dry. If it needs to shrink more, I pop it into the dryer when it is damp, almost dry. I find this reduces the amount of wonky stretching as well as pilling that can happen even with the gentle cycle.

    Silk also shrinks like crazy! Before choosing an item to shrink, I ask myself if there is any dimension that would be too small as a result of shrinking. Beware of small neck openings! Ha ha nothing worse than not being able to stick your head through afterwards. As you said, often the garment will shrink in all dimensions, so it’s perfect for something that you want to have smaller all over. :)

    • Reply January 20, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Oh boy, I’ve never tried to shrink silk, but for some reason that though scares me! Does it get all wrinkly and bumpy afterwards?

      • Reply January 20, 2012

        Leslie

        I did a couple of blouses that were too wide, too long, and the supposed 3/4 sleeves were awkwardly long. Turned out perfect! I actually machine washed gentle and put them in the dryer. The dryer smoothes out any creases, and the crispness returns after a quick press with an iron. I would only do it once though. I suspect repeated washing and drying would weaken the fabric.

        So hard to find a well-fitting blouse!

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Sayaka

    Although I don’t buy too many JCrew items either, this is very useful!! Thanks for sharing. And I think the sweater looks really pretty on you!! 

  • Reply January 19, 2012

    Anonymous

    Thanks for the helpful guide. I have AE sweater that get tighter every time I wash it but length is still the same. I guess it must be the material.

    • Reply January 20, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      I’m pretty sure that has to do with the direction of the weave in the fabric. Fabric threads will shrink more in length than in width, so if all the threads in the sweater are going in one direction, that’s the only direction they’ll shrink. Weird, right? =)

  • Reply January 21, 2012

    Little_jlai

    Hi thank you so much for sharing! The shrunken version definitely looks much nicer on you. I’m 4’8″ and 75 lbs, i have real problem with finding clothes that fit well. May i ask you to clarify “dried in dryer for short bursts of time” ? Do you mean you let it dry for 5 minutes in the dryer at a time and then check on it before popping it back to the dryer for another 5 minutes? I’m not sure how long you leave it in the dryer and if you “pause” the drying time…. Thanks for clarifying!

    • Reply January 21, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Hi Little_jlai! I put the sweater in the dryer for about 10 minutes at a time. Then I would take it out, look at it, and pop it back in again for another 10 minutes. After a few cycles like that (3 I think), I finally just let it air dry flat overnight.

  • Reply February 5, 2012

    Sea Cricket

    Coming out of lurk mode for a minute here to say thank you for this idea.  I tried this to great success and now don’t have to lose yet another sweater to the Goodwill bin.  Wish I’d taken before and after pics, though–duh.  The sweater was a lightweight J.Crew cashmere/wool blend cable knit in cotton candy pink that was about 2-3 sizes too big overall–sleeve length, arm hole drop, waist, garment length.  When I bought it I thought it’d be great for a slouchy look but instead I just looked unkempt and sloppy.  Washed that puppy in a garment bag on cold/delicate, air dried it for about 20 minutes and voila–fits perfectly in every way.  What a nice surprise!  Getting ready to rip apart my closet to find some more offending sweaters that I can torture into submission.  Love your blog!

    • Reply February 5, 2012

      Alterations Needed

       Wonderful! I’m so happy this worked on your sweater! So many of my sweaters and cardigans have gone through this same torture. Just be careful with really lose weaves and merino wool…those tend to shrink a little too much. =)

  • Reply June 16, 2012

    GUEST

    After shrinking fits better! Good idea! BTW, what’s the size of Shoulder: 14″, XS or XXS ? Thanks~:)

    • Reply June 16, 2012

      Alterations Needed

      Thank you! The size xxs had a 14″ shoulder pre-shrinking and after shrinking measured about 13″.

Leave a Reply